Success Book

A class or individual record book where examples of work that meets or exceeds success criteria are collected and celebrated, providing concrete models of quality for future reference.

Assessment for learning
Success Book diagram

What is success book?

  • Create a class success book (a physical book, folder, or display)
  • When work meets or exceeds a success criterion, add it to the book with an annotation
  • Use the book as a reference for future tasks to show what quality looks like
  • Celebrate additions to the book so learners aspire to contribute

How it works

A success book is a growing collection of exemplary work. When a learner produces something that particularly well demonstrates a success criterion, it is added to the book. The work is annotated to explain what makes it successful, so the book becomes a reference resource, not just a showcase.

The annotation is critical. Without it, the success book is a collection of "best work" with no learning value. With it, the book teaches future learners what quality looks like and why. An annotation might read: "This paragraph demonstrates the success criterion 'use evidence to support your argument' because the learner includes a direct quote and explains how it supports their point."

The success book should include work from a range of learners, not just the highest attainers. A piece of work from a learner who has made significant progress, even if it is not the "best" in the class, can be the most powerful example. This communicates that success is about meeting criteria and making progress, not about being the most able.

Use the success book actively. Before starting a task, open the book and show examples from previous classes or earlier in the term. Ask: "What made this successful? How could you achieve something similar in your work today?" This makes the criteria concrete and achievable.

Classroom example

A Year 5 Expressive Arts class in a Carmarthenshire school keeps a success book for their art portfolio. When a learner's colour-mixing work demonstrates the criterion "blend two colours to create a smooth gradient," the teacher photographs it and adds it to the book with an annotation explaining the technique used. Before the next colour-mixing lesson, the teacher shows the success book example. Learners study it and discuss the blending technique before starting their own work.

Curriculum for Wales connection

Success books develop the "Reflect" strand of thinking skills by making success criteria visible and concrete. They support the Four Purposes by developing "ambitious, capable learners" who understand what quality looks like and can aspire to it, and build cross-curricular literacy through annotated examples across all AoLEs.

Rainbow Curriculum's Thinking Tools lens helps you plan where exemplification is embedded across your curriculum, ensuring that models of quality are available in every subject.

Tips

  • Annotate every entry. An unannotated piece of work does not teach anything about what makes it good.
  • Include work from a range of learners and abilities to communicate inclusive messages about success.
  • A common pitfall: creating the book and then forgetting to use it. Schedule regular "success book moments" into lessons.
  • Allow learners to nominate their own work for the book, explaining which criterion it meets.
  • Digital versions (shared folders or class blogs) work well and are easier to search and share.

Source: Adapted from "How to develop thinking and assessment for learning in the classroom", Welsh Assembly Government, Guidance 044/2010.